Click here to access our COVID-19 resource center.

Who are the Best Insurance Agencies on Cape Cod?


Each year, RogersGray Insurance services thousands of clients on Cape Cod with respect to their insurance programs. But in the Google world we live in, it’s not hard to find other insurance agencies on Cape Cod right and every once in a while we even get asked “Who are the best insurance agencies on Cape Cod?”

With 6 offices on the Cape & Islands (Dennis, Orleans, Hyannis, Nantucket, Falmouth and Sandwich), RogersGray is definitely the largest local insurance agency with access to the most amount of carriers. We were also voted “Best Agency to Work for in the US”, serve all 50 states and ranks in the top 100 agencies in the country.

Even though we’re proud of our client services and our people, we certainly not going to say we’re the only game in town. So – we thought we’d share and help answer the question.

Here is a list of some other insurance agencies on Cape Cod that have a solid reputation and history on the Cape.

  1. Dowling and O’Neill – located in Hyannis, D&O is a long time agency (even older than RogersGray!) who specializes in personal and business insurance. They also have a focus on Physicians and Physician groups.
  2. Murray & McDonald – Again, another long-time Cape Cod Insurance operation, Murray & McDonald has offices in Bourne and Falmouth.  They are licensed in all the New England states as well as a few others including California, Florida, and Missouri.
  3. Kerry Insurance Agency – Kerry Insurance is a great agency with offices in Eastham and Orleans and is very involved in Community efforts – particularly in the lower cape area.
  4. Benson, Young and Downs – With offices in Wellfleet, Harwich and Provincetown, BYD has a great team and good coverage.

There are a lot of questions around insurance for cars, homes, apartments etc…and we’re happy to help with resources.

Umbrella Insurance and Social Host Laws
What Insurance is needed for a Seasonal Rental
Why Homeowners Should Ask for Proof Of Insurance from Contractors

We have a FAQ page on our site or to have a question answered from RogersGray – simply enter your info here or give us a buzz at 877-504-7192.



Contact Us

434 Route 134
South Dennis, MA 02660

Phone: 508-619-4545

Fax: 877-816-2156

24 Hour Emergency Claims Center:



Get helpful tips, and insurance insights delivered right to your inbox!